A Blow to Blaine Amendments

A Case for Preventing Children's Scraped Knees
George F. Will: A case for preventing children's scraped knees
Author

20 April, 2017

Until the argument, the case had appeared in danger of being derailed by a last-minute policy change.

Trinity Lutheran Church applied for a grant to resurface its preschool playground.

A strong ruling for Trinity would no doubt make it tougher for opponents to challenge school voucher programs in Blaine Amendment states.

Inside the Court on Wednesday, the justices pressed Cortman on whether the playground would be used for religious purposes and if that effectively constituted state funding of religious ministry.

"You're depriving one set of actors from being able to compete in the same way everybody else can compete, due to their religious identification", Justice Elena Kagan told a lawyer for the state.

Kagan pointed out that the selective program was offered to nonprofits.

This is clearly singling out a religious organization, with no justification. "It's a hard issue", Justice Elena Kagan said. "And then your interests have to rise to an extremely high level".

"We aren't asking for special treatment", continued Kiehne. If so, he said, why can Missouri "deny money for helping children not fall in the playground, cut their knees, get tetanus (or) break a leg"?

Liberal Justice Sonia Sotomayor was the most outspoken in backing Missouri's ban, referencing the difficulty states could face in separating out the secular and religious functions of religiously affiliated groups when distributing funds.

It is "quintessential discrimination" on the part of Missouri, Cruz said.

Trinity Lutheran's insistence that its playground resurfacing project is secular does not solve the problem, adds the state, because money is fungible, and because the church's religious intent is stated specifically in the Learning Center's mission. Ginsburg asked whether that precedent was "passé". The court Friday asked the church and the state to tell it whether the governor's announcement affects the case.

More news: San Bernardino School Shooting: Slain Teacher, Student & Shooter Identified

But Justice Sotomayor noted that there were many cases in which states refused to fund churches, and that ruling against the church in this case wouldn't impede it from practicing its religion. He said that the state had conceded its denial of funding was "not facially neutral" and was "based on their religious character", thus making it "discrimination against religion". "The Supreme Court has previously suggested that they can, where the funding would otherwise support religious activities". The program was created to assist non-profit organizations in updating their playgrounds and making them safer, but because the Missouri constitution prohibits state money from going to religious organizations, Trinity Lutheran's application was denied.

If your heart goes out to religious groups denied state aid under this prohibition, take comfort in the fact that the governor of Missouri actually reversed it last Thursday.

David Cortman, a lawyer for the church, said it sought only to protect children of all faiths from injury and could not use the rubber in its religious work.

The church's case is for a "safe surface", Cortman replied, and just because the playground might be used for religious purposes does not mean that it should be ineligible for the funds.

But Trinity Lutheran and its lawyer argued protecting kids on a playground isn't going to promote religion and shouldn't be discriminated against.

Becket attorney Hannah Smith says the state rejected the application because Trinity is a religious institution. It will also be the biggest test for the court's newest justice, Neil Gorsuch, who was appointed by President Donald Trump. It also guarantees religion can be fully exercised.

Greitens' decision is a unsafe threat to religious freedom. These provisions forbid the use of any tax money to support churches or church schools.

The case has been a longtime coming to the Supreme Court which agreed to hear the case more than a year ago, a month before the death of Justice Antonin Scalia.

Oral arguments were held today in what is perhaps the most high-profile case remaining to be argued this term: Trinity Lutheran Church of Columbia v. Comer. "Nearly 40 state constitutions have similar constitutional provisions that opponents of school choice have tried to invoke in the past to halt school choice programs in their tracks", he said.

The court did not appear ready to scuttle the case, even after Gov. Eric Greitens, R-Mo., announced last week that he was changing the policy that said churches couldn't participate in the program.

"That's just wrong", he said. Jeffrey Mittman, the director of Missouri's branch of the American Civil Liberties Union, is among Greitens' critics who said that his move violates the state's constitution.


More news


  • Panthers sign DT Kawann Short to 5-year extension

    Panthers sign DT Kawann Short to 5-year extension

    He had a slow start last season but did manage six sacks and the Panthers placed the franchise tag on him back in February. We've all been told about how much Dave Gettleman values his hog mollies and pass rushers, but this deal really proved it.

    Japan PM: NKorea may be capable of sarin-loaded missiles

    According to South Korea's 2016 Defense White Paper, North Korea has been developing chemical weapons since 1980. South Korea has long said it believes the North can conduct its sixth nuclear test whenever it chooses.
    US National Security Adviser Arrives in Afghanistan Days after MOAB Strike

    US National Security Adviser Arrives in Afghanistan Days after MOAB Strike

    General McMaster thanked the Adviser and acknowledged Pakistan's sacrifices in combating extremism and terrorism. McMaster's visit to Kabul came shortly after the U.S. bomb strike on Afghanistan's eastern province.
  • 5 things to know about Tax Day: Refunds are up, audits down

    5 things to know about Tax Day: Refunds are up, audits down

    In West Palm Beach, some of those marching said they'd taken part in protests nearly every weekend since Trump was sworn in. Trump has a responsibility to share his tax returns to give transparency to the American public", Rosenthal said .

    Hillary Clinton spied on her own campaign staff

    When Clinton delivered her concession speech on the morning after Trump's victory, she tried to strike a hopeful tone. And he would talk about how then-Republican nominee Donald Trump was wrong about climate change and the economy.

    Trump says US-Russia relations may be at "all-time low"

    He said Moscow has lots of questions about the "very ambiguous" and "contradictory" ideas emanating from Washington . Disagreement over Assad's role in the chemical attack remained an area of tension during the press conference.
  • International Monetary Fund raises China growth forecast to 6.6% this year, 6.2% in 2018

    They also expect President Donald Trump to deliver tax cuts and infrastructure spending that could help boost US economic growth. At the same time, adverse weather conditions and civil unrest threaten several low-income countries with starvation.

    Donald Trump the Golfer

    The Trump Organization, which operates the family's business empire, did not immediately respond to an email requesting comment. If he never took another trip to Mar-a-Lago, he would have to remain president for 171 years to make up the difference.
    Arrest made in connection to murder of Princeton jogger Vanessa Marcotte

    Arrest made in connection to murder of Princeton jogger Vanessa Marcotte

    Early said that he anticipates bringing a murder charge against Colon-Ortiz as the investigation progresses. State police detectives and local police previously said they received more than 1,300 tips in the case.
  • Here's how the H-1B visa program works

    Pinchuk said he believes it's actually the "seminal issue of our time", because we're in a global competition for jobs. India has a message for President Trump: Curbing visas for skilled workers won't solve America's problems.
    Russia, Google reach $7.8 million settlement on Android case

    Russia, Google reach $7.8 million settlement on Android case

    Not only is the company being fined $7.8 million Dollars , but it has agreed to allow the pre-installation of third-party apps. The dispute arose after Russia-based search company Yandex submitted a complaint to the FAS about Google's practices.
    Chappelle salutes Murphy at Mayer concert

    Chappelle salutes Murphy at Mayer concert

    Murphy grew up in Brooklyn, and after a short jail sentence as a young man, he joined the Navy, where he served for six years. Mayer and Chappelle are good friends, and the singer once appeared in a sketch on the Comedy Central series.