Supreme Court strikes down 2 NC congressional districts

Author

24 May, 2017

This law was put in place during the Civil Rights Movement to obstruct voting for African-Americans in historically racist states as part of the systemic discrimination known as Jim Crow laws, which were adopted in the century following the abolition of slavery. "The issue is whether District 12 was drawn predominantly because of race".

Georgia may feel the effects of the U.S. Supreme Court decision overruling voting districts in North Carolina.

"This will lead to many more successful racial gerrymandering cases in the American South and elsewhere, and allow these cases to substitute for (so far unsuccessful) partisan gerrymandering claims involving some of these districts", Hasen wrote on his blog.

President Donald Trump's former national security adviser, Michael Flynn, invoked his constitutional right against self-incrimination on Monday and declined to hand over documents sought under subpoena by a Senate panel investigating Russia's meddling in the 2016 election.

"Even if the minority party loses in court, it can exact a heavy price by using the judicial process to engage in political trench warfare for years on end".

The court rejected the argument from North Carolina lawmakers that the goal of drawing the maps was not race discrimination but an attempt to gain a partisan advantage. At the same time, race can't be the predominant factor without very strong reasons, under a series of high court decisions.

Michael Li, a redistricting expert and senior counsel at New York University's Brennan Center for Justice, said the North Carolina ruling will be an "important decision" for the other districting efforts winding through the legal system, including those in Texas. "Neither will we approve a racial gerrymander whose necessity is supported by no evidence and whose raison d'être is a legal mistake". What did surprise them was that the 5-3 verdict, with the fifth vote cast by conservative justice Clarence Thomas, has made challenging gerrymandering much easier in court.

Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., Justice Anthony M. Kennedy, and Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. dissented, agreeing with state officials that the districts lines were not racially motivated but rather to benefit Republicans, something that the court has never said lawmakers could not do.

More news: Moon, Turnbull agree to jointly fight trade protectionism

Justice Neil Gorsuch, who had not yet joined the court when it heard arguments in the case in December, did not participate.

In regard to District 12, the state maintained the race played no role in the creation of the district. In 2012 and 2014, when the statewide vote was closely divided, Republicans won 10 of the state's 13 House seats.

"The evidence offered at trial.adequately supports the conclusion that race, not politics, accounted for the district's reconfiguration", Kagan wrote. However, the court's decision will send legislators back to the drawing board - a setback that could spell trouble for Republicans in the upcoming 2018 midterm election.

The Supreme Court deferred to the district court's decision on CD12.

States reconsider districts following each census, and the endeavor is a political football. Likewise in District 12, a narrow area in western North Carolina, the number increased to 50.7 percent from 43.8 percent. The new map has likewise been challenged in court by critics who call it overly partisan.

While the districts have already been redrawn, Amy Auth, a spokeswoman for Senate Leader Phil Berger, said Monday that the uncertainty in the court's decisions on this case have made redistricting hard. It added more African Americans to two districts that already had significant black populations and had consistently elected the representatives-all Democrats-favored by most black voters since the 1990s.

They lost, and now North Carolina may be facing the challenge of drawing new lines and having elections in 2017.


More news


  • Trump administration extends protected status for Haitians

    Trump administration extends protected status for Haitians

    Haiti's TPS designation expires in July of this year, which means that Haitians with this status may be deported from the U.S. The U.S. government official, who has been briefed on the decision, said the program will continue until January.
    Celtics follow euphoria of winning lottery with dud on court

    Celtics follow euphoria of winning lottery with dud on court

    The Charlotte Hornets , Detroit Pistons , Denver Nuggets and Miami Heat will get the final four lottery picks. The Los Angeles Lakers were other big winners, moving up one spot to second to hold onto their pick.
    REAL ID Finally a Done Deal in Minnesota

    REAL ID Finally a Done Deal in Minnesota

    But what lawmakers will be doing during that time is not at all clear. But Republicans say it's normal to include policy in budgets. Daudt balked at the idea but said he would hear out Gazelka.
  • Monaco win Ligue 1 title

    Monaco win Ligue 1 title

    AS Monaco allowed the second least shots per game (9.5), and have given up the second least goals in the league as well (29).
    NASCAR driver Aric Almirola says he felt 'helpless' in Saturday's awful  wreck

    NASCAR driver Aric Almirola says he felt 'helpless' in Saturday's awful wreck

    Being out 8-12 weeks and not having a chance at the Playoffs, obviously that stinks, especially coming off Talladega". Richard Petty Motorsports driver Aric Almirola talked about his broken back and his future Friday in North Carolina.
    Takata air bag settlement delivers $553M to consumers for economic losses

    Takata air bag settlement delivers $553M to consumers for economic losses

    Lawsuits against Honda Motor Company HMC, Ford Motor Company F and Nissan Motor have not been settled yet, per the lawyers. The solution for a mass recall on defective Takata airbags is under way, though it seems to be far from over.
  • Trump hopes to nominate new Federal Bureau of Investigation  director quickly

    Trump hopes to nominate new Federal Bureau of Investigation director quickly

    Rosenstein will come to brief the full Senate next week", Schumer spokesman Matt House said in a statement. The New York Times has since reported that the president asked Mr.
    Pueblo will dodge snow in latest storm

    Pueblo will dodge snow in latest storm

    The weather service says there could be occasional rain Thursday afternoon and overnight, with a low in the 30s. Arapahoe Basin, the only ski area still open in Colorado, was reveling in a foot or more of fresh snow.
    Merkel says open to principle of reciprocity in trade policy

    Merkel says open to principle of reciprocity in trade policy

    Macron said "treaty change long used to be a French taboo", but that this would change now that he was president. Mr Macron wants to create a common eurozone budget, parliament and finance minister.
  • Colton Sissons: Colton Sissons leads Predators to Cup final

    His third goal, with six minutes left in the third period, made it 4-3 for the Preds and turned out to be the game victor . Not even half of the opening period had elapsed by the time the Predators took a two-goal lead. (AP Photo/Mark Humphrey).

    Ducks captain Ryan Getzlaf fined for apparent homophobic slur

    The schedule doesn't allow such a break with both the Predators and Ducks back on planes Sunday for the return trip to Tennessee. Ryan Johansen left game 4 and required emergency hip surgery which will cost him and the Preds the remainder of the playoffs.
    West Ham fans urge Bilic to give youngster a chance next season

    West Ham fans urge Bilic to give youngster a chance next season

    Adrian admits he wishes the season was not coming to an end now that he has finally found his way back into Slaven Bilic's graces. Bilic also confirmed that defender Winston Reid would be out for around 10 weeks after undergoing surgery on a knee injury.